There is a small but persistent temptation in the spiritual life to postpone gratitude until everything has been properly arranged.
We will be thankful when the problem is solved.
We will be thankful when the diagnosis is better.
We will be thankful when the children are settled, the mortgage is smaller, the congregation is behaving itself, the government has regained its senses, and the person driving seventeen kilometres below the speed limit finally turns off the road.
Then, presumably, we shall become enormously grateful people.
Unfortunately, life appears to have received no notice of this arrangement.
Something is nearly always unfinished.
Something is nearly always worrying us.
Something is nearly always sitting on the kitchen counter waiting to be dealt with.
And just when we have finally solved one problem, another arrives with the cheerful punctuality of someone who has misunderstood an invitation.
This creates a difficulty for those of us who have decided that thanksgiving should begin when life becomes satisfactory.
Because life is rarely entirely satisfactory.
It is beautiful.
It is heartbreaking.
It is ridiculous.
It is holy.
It is occasionally all four before breakfast.
And perhaps this is precisely where Christian thanksgiving begins.
Not when everything is fixed.
But here.
Gratitude in the Middle of Things
The Scriptures have an inconvenient habit of placing thanksgiving in situations where sensible people might have postponed it.
The psalmists praise God while surrounded by enemies.
Paul gives thanks while writing from prison.
Jesus gives thanks before distributing five loaves and two fish to a crowd large enough to make any church catering committee resign immediately.
There is something wonderfully strange about that moment.
Jesus does not look at the five loaves and say, “Well, this is obviously inadequate.”
He gives thanks.
Before the multiplication.
Before everyone is fed.
Before the problem is solved.
He gives thanks while the resources still appear insufficient.
That detail matters.
Because it suggests that thanksgiving is not merely our response after God has provided.
Sometimes thanksgiving is how we learn to recognize that God is already providing.
We look at what we have and see scarcity.
Christ looks at what is present and gives thanks.
And somewhere between those two ways of seeing the world lies much of the spiritual life.
The Myth of the Perfect Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving celebrations themselves can become an excellent illustration of this.
We imagine the perfect table.
The turkey emerges from the oven looking as though it has spent the afternoon posing for a magazine.
The vegetables are colourful.
The potatoes are fluffy.
The gravy behaves.
Everyone arrives on time.
No one discusses politics.
No child announces that they hate everything on their plate.
No relative asks an unexpectedly personal question while the cranberry sauce is being passed.
This gathering has probably occurred somewhere.
I have never attended it.
Real thanksgiving tables are considerably more human.
Someone is late.
Something is overcooked.
Someone forgot something.
Two people are carefully avoiding a subject that everyone else knows about.
The cook insists they are not tired while displaying every known symptom of exhaustion.
And at some point somebody discovers that the rolls have been warming in the oven since approximately the reign of Queen Victoria.
And yet grace arrives.
Not because the meal was perfect.
Because people gathered.
Because there was food.
Because there was laughter.
Because someone pulled out another chair.
Because a story was told that everyone had heard before and everyone laughed anyway.
Because someone who was missing was remembered.
Because, for a little while, ordinary people sat around an ordinary table and received one another again.
Perhaps that is enough.
Perhaps it is more than enough.
Thanksgiving Does Not Deny Sorrow
There is an important distinction here.
Christian gratitude is not pretending everything is wonderful.
Some things are not wonderful.
Some Thanksgiving tables have an empty chair this year.
Some families are carrying grief.
Some people are frightened about money.
Some are waiting for medical results.
Some relationships remain painfully unresolved.
Some prayers seem to have disappeared into silence.
Faith does not require us to paint cheerful scenery over genuine sorrow.
Jesus wept.
The psalms lament.
The prophets protest.
Christianity has never taught that faithful people must smile continuously like employees in an advertisement for toothpaste.
Thanksgiving does not require the denial of grief.
It asks whether grief is the only truth about our lives.
It asks whether, even here, something remains that can still be received as gift.
Perhaps there is a friend who called.
Perhaps there is a neighbour who noticed.
Perhaps there is bread on the table.
Perhaps there is strength enough for today.
Perhaps there is a memory that still makes us smile.
Perhaps there is simply the astonishing fact that God has not gone anywhere.
Give Us This Day
Jesus teaches us to pray:
“Give us this day our daily bread.”
I have always been struck by the modesty of that prayer.
Not next month’s bread.
Not enough bread to guarantee that nothing difficult will ever happen.
Today’s bread.
Enough grace for today.
Enough courage for today.
Enough forgiveness for today.
Enough hope for today.
Enough strength to take the next faithful step.
We often want God to provide certainty.
God frequently provides daily bread.
And perhaps one of the great disciplines of thanksgiving is learning to stop overlooking today’s bread because we are worried about tomorrow’s menu.
Grace usually arrives in daily portions.
A conversation.
A meal.
A sunrise.
A kindness.
A moment of laughter.
A prayer whispered while washing dishes.
A hand held in a hospital room.
A cup of coffee placed beside us without being asked.
Small things.
Ordinary things.
Holy things.
The Eucharistic Life
For Christians, thanksgiving eventually leads us to the altar.
The word Eucharist itself means thanksgiving.
And there is something deeply important about what happens there.
We bring bread.
We bring wine.
Very ordinary things.
The products of fields, vineyards, labour, weather, patience and human hands.
And then we say thank you.
Not because the world is perfect.
The Eucharist has been celebrated during wars.
During plagues.
During persecutions.
Beside hospital beds.
In prisons.
At funerals.
In tiny churches wondering whether they will survive another decade.
At altars surrounded by people carrying burdens no one else can see.
And still the Church says:
Let us give thanks to the Lord our God.
Not because everything has been fixed.
Because Christ is present.
That changes thanksgiving entirely.
Our gratitude is not based upon the belief that nothing terrible will happen.
It rests upon the promise that nothing — absolutely nothing — can separate us from the love of God revealed in Jesus Christ.
Which means thanksgiving can begin even while some things remain unfinished.
Thank God Now
Perhaps there is something in your life you have been waiting to resolve before allowing yourself to be grateful.
A decision.
A relationship.
A worry.
A prayer.
A future you cannot yet see clearly.
You do not need to pretend it does not matter.
You do not need to stop praying about it.
You do not need to manufacture optimism.
But perhaps, alongside that unfinished thing, you might notice what is already here.
What bread has been given today?
Who has loved you?
What beauty did you almost miss?
What strength appeared when you needed it?
Where did grace quietly place something into your hands?
Then say thank you.
Not eventually.
Now.
Because perhaps one of the deepest lessons of Thanksgiving is this:
We do not give thanks because everything has finally become good. We give thanks because, even in an unfinished life, God is still good.
And that may be enough gratitude for today.
Tomorrow, by the grace of God, there will be more daily bread.
And probably another problem.
But there will be grace there too.
Follow along on Instagram @renewablespiritual for more daily reflections on faith, life, and the surprising places where God still loves to meet us.
A Prayer for an Unfinished Life
Gracious God,
teach us to give thanks
not only when prayers are answered,
problems are solved,
and the road ahead is clear,
but here, in the middle of our unfinished lives.
Open our eyes to the daily bread already before us:
the people who love us,
the beauty we nearly overlook,
the strength sufficient for today,
and the quiet gifts of grace
you continually place into our hands.
When sorrow is real, give us courage to name it.
When tomorrow is uncertain, give us faith to trust you.
And in all things, remind us that our thanksgiving rests
not upon everything being well,
but upon the promise that you are with us still.
For today’s bread, today’s grace,
and your unfailing love,
we give you thanks.
Through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Amen.